Illustration: a yellow SUV driving the Pacific Coast Highway
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. No-Cost Lemon Law Claims: How California Law Forces Automakers to Pay Your Attorney Fees

Lemon Law

No-Cost Lemon Law Claims: How California Law Forces Automakers to Pay Your Attorney Fees

805-342-0555
Photorealistic image of a sleek modern car parked in front of a California courthouse with palm trees in the background, warm

Summary

  • California’s Lemon Law includes a powerful fee-shifting provision that requires automakers — not consumers — to pay your attorney fees when you win.
  • You can hire an experienced Lemon Law attorney at zero out-of-pocket cost, making legal help accessible to every California vehicle owner.
  • Attorneys Derek Johnson and Jonathan Buxton of Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys spent years on the manufacturer’s side, giving them unique insider knowledge to maximize your recovery.

Most people assume that hiring a lawyer costs a lot of money upfront. When your car is broken and you are already dealing with repair bills and rental cars, the last thing you need is a big legal invoice.

Here is the good news: California’s Lemon Law is specifically designed to flip that equation. The law forces automakers to foot the bill for your attorney fees — not you. This page explains exactly how that works and what it means for your case.

What does “the manufacturer pays your attorney fees” actually mean?

It means that when you win your Lemon Law case, the automaker — not you — is legally required to pay the reasonable attorney fees and costs your lawyer earned. This is called a “fee-shifting” provision, and it is built directly into California law.

Fee-shifting exists to level the playing field. Automakers have teams of in-house lawyers and deep pockets. Without fee-shifting, most consumers could never afford to fight back.

Because of this rule, Lemon Law attorneys like those at Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys can represent you at absolutely no upfront cost to you. You pay nothing out of pocket — ever.

The requirement comes from the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, California’s primary Lemon Law statute. You can read the full text at California Civil Code Section 1794, which is the enforcement section of the law.

Specifically, Civil Code Section 1794(d) states that a buyer who prevails in a Lemon Law action is entitled to recover “a sum equal to the aggregate amount of costs and expenses, including attorney’s fees based on actual time expended, determined by the court to have been reasonably incurred by the buyer in connection with the commencement and prosecution of such action.”

In plain English: the court orders the manufacturer to pay your lawyer’s reasonable fees. The statute leaves no wiggle room on this point when you prevail.

California also has additional consumer protection tools. The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, enforced by the Federal Trade Commission, provides a parallel federal layer of protection for consumers with defective products, including vehicles, and also includes fee-shifting for prevailing consumers.

How does the fee payment process actually work in practice?

Your attorney handles the entire case on your behalf. They file the claim, gather evidence, negotiate with the manufacturer’s legal team, and — if needed — take the case to court. You do not write any checks along the way.

When the case resolves, either through a settlement or a court judgment, attorney fees are addressed as part of that resolution. In a settlement, fees are typically negotiated as a separate line item that the manufacturer pays directly. In a court judgment, the judge awards fees based on the time your attorney reasonably spent on your case.

Either way, the money flows from the automaker to your lawyer — not from your wallet. Your recovery stays yours.

What does it mean to “prevail” in a Lemon Law case?

You “prevail” when you obtain a court judgment in your favor or when the manufacturer agrees to a settlement that gives you meaningful relief. Relief usually means a buyback of your vehicle, a replacement vehicle, or a cash settlement.

The vast majority of California Lemon Law cases settle before trial. When a manufacturer offers a buyback or a substantial cash payment, that typically qualifies as a prevailing outcome that triggers the fee obligation.

This matters because it means you do not need to go all the way to trial to have the manufacturer pay fees. A negotiated settlement can accomplish the same result. The attorneys at Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys know exactly how to push manufacturers to the settlement table — and they know all the tactics manufacturers use to delay or minimize payouts, because they spent years defending those same manufacturers before switching sides to represent consumers exclusively.

Wondering what counts as enough repair attempts to qualify? Check out our resource on what to do when your dealer says it’s fixed but the problem keeps coming back for a detailed breakdown.

Does the no-cost rule apply to every type of vehicle?

Yes — as long as the vehicle came with a manufacturer’s warranty and the defect arose within that warranty period, the fee-shifting rule applies. This covers new cars, trucks, SUVs, certified pre-owned vehicles, leased vehicles, motorcycles, and RVs.

California’s Song-Beverly Act is notably broad. According to the California Attorney General’s consumer protection page, the law covers “any new motor vehicle” bought or used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes. The law also extends to used vehicles that are still covered by the original manufacturer’s warranty or a dealer-certified warranty.

So whether you bought a brand-new pickup truck, leased an SUV, or purchased a certified pre-owned sedan that still had factory warranty coverage, you may have full Lemon Law rights — and you can pursue them at zero cost to you.

Even motorcycles and recreational vehicles are covered. California consumers often do not realize how broad this protection really is.

Will the automaker try to fight or reduce the attorney fee award?

Yes, manufacturers frequently challenge the amount of fees — even after losing or settling on the underlying claim. This is one of the most important reasons to hire an attorney who has specific Lemon Law experience, not just a general practice lawyer.

Automakers and their legal teams are experienced at arguing that fees should be reduced. They may claim certain hours were unnecessary, that rates are too high, or that the work was duplicative. These are not just standard legal arguments — they are deliberate strategies designed to shrink the final fee award.

Derek Johnson and Jonathan Buxton spent years on the defense side at major law firms, defending automakers against exactly these types of claims. They know every argument manufacturers use — because they used those same arguments themselves. Now they use that insider knowledge exclusively to protect consumers and push back hard against fee reduction tactics.

To make sure you are giving your attorney every tool to build the strongest case — and the best fee record — start your documentation early. Our California Lemon Law Documentation Checklist walks you through everything you need to gather from day one.

What other costs and money can you recover besides attorney fees?

Attorney fees are just one part of your potential recovery. Under California’s Lemon Law, a successful claimant can also recover the full purchase or lease price of the vehicle, minus a reasonable offset for the miles you drove before the problems started.

You may also be entitled to reimbursement for incidental costs you paid because of the defect. These can include repair costs you paid out of pocket, towing fees, rental car expenses, and even registration fees you cannot get back.

If the manufacturer acted willfully — meaning they knew about the defect and still refused to fix it or buy the vehicle back — the court can award up to two times your actual damages as a civil penalty. This is sometimes called “two times” or “double damages” and it is a powerful tool to hold bad actors accountable.

The full breakdown of available remedies is in Civil Code Section 1794. An experienced attorney will evaluate your specific facts to determine which remedies apply to your case.

For specific vehicle issues that could qualify, see our post on Chevy Silverado Lemon Law issues as one example of how defects in popular models can give rise to strong claims.

How do you start a no-cost Lemon Law claim in California?

The first step is simple: reach out to a qualified California Lemon Law attorney for a free case evaluation. You do not need to have all the answers or know whether your vehicle qualifies. That is what the consultation is for.

When you contact Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys, you will speak directly with attorneys who have handled hundreds of Lemon Law cases — and who spent years learning the system from the inside by defending automakers. That background gives them a level of strategic insight that most consumer attorneys simply do not have.

Here is what to expect from the process:

  1. Free consultation: You describe your vehicle, the problems, and your repair history. The attorneys assess whether you have a qualifying claim.
  2. No retainer, no fees: If they take your case, you sign a contingency agreement. You pay nothing unless you win — and even then, the manufacturer pays the fees, not you.
  3. Case building: Your attorney gathers repair orders, warranty documents, communications with the dealer, and any other evidence needed.
  4. Demand and negotiation: A formal demand is sent to the manufacturer. Most cases settle at this stage.
  5. Resolution: You receive your buyback, replacement vehicle, or cash settlement. The manufacturer pays your attorney fees separately.

You can also educate yourself further by visiting the Johnson & Buxton blog, which covers specific vehicle defects, manufacturer issues, and updates to California Lemon Law on an ongoing basis.

The California Department of Consumer Affairs also maintains a helpful overview of your rights at dca.ca.gov. Reading it alongside a consultation with a Lemon Law attorney will give you a complete picture of where you stand.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I really pay nothing even if I lose my Lemon Law case?

In most cases, yes. Most Lemon Law attorneys in California work on a contingency basis, meaning they only collect fees if you win. If your case does not succeed, you typically owe no attorney fees. Always confirm the fee structure with your attorney at the start of your consultation.

Does the manufacturer pay my attorney directly, or does the money go through me?

Attorney fees are typically paid directly by the manufacturer or resolved as a separate line item in the settlement. Your personal recovery — the buyback amount, reimbursements, and any penalties — is separate from and not reduced by the attorney fee payment.

What if the manufacturer offers me a settlement before I hire a lawyer? Should I accept it?

You should speak with a Lemon Law attorney before accepting any offer from a manufacturer. Early offers are often significantly lower than what you are entitled to under California law. Once you accept and sign a release, it may be very difficult or impossible to go back for more.

How many repair attempts do I need before I can file a Lemon Law claim?

There is no single magic number, but California law establishes a rebuttable presumption that a vehicle is a lemon if the same serious defect has not been fixed after two or more repair attempts, or if any defect has not been resolved after four or more attempts, or if the vehicle has been out of service for 30 or more cumulative days due to repairs — all within the first 18 months or 18,000 miles. However, even if you fall outside these numbers, you may still have a valid claim.

Does the no-cost model apply to leased vehicles too?

Yes. California’s Song-Beverly Act covers leased vehicles as well as purchased ones. If your leased vehicle has a qualifying defect that the manufacturer cannot fix in a reasonable number of attempts, you have the same Lemon Law rights as a buyer — and the same fee-shifting rules apply.

Can I file a Lemon Law claim on a used car?

Possibly. If your used vehicle is still covered by the original manufacturer’s warranty or a certified pre-owned warranty at the time the defect appears, you may qualify. The key is whether a warranty was in place when the problem arose. An attorney can evaluate your specific situation quickly.

How long does a California Lemon Law case typically take?

Many cases resolve within a few months through negotiated settlements. Cases that require litigation can take longer. Your attorney will give you a realistic timeline based on the specific manufacturer, the strength of your evidence, and the nature of the defect.


Legal Disclaimer: This blog post is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every Lemon Law case is unique, and the outcome of any case depends on the specific facts and circumstances involved. California law governs the rights described in this article. Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys is licensed to practice law in the State of California only. If you believe you have a Lemon Law claim, you should consult with a qualified California attorney to evaluate your individual situation. Do not rely on this article as a substitute for personalized legal advice.

Talk To A California Lemon Law Lawyer Today.

The car manufacturer pays all legal fees. You have nothing to lose.

Call 805-342-0555